The Honest Quant.
Open the Lab

The macd zero-line cross vs the MACD histogram flip: which is more honest?

Two textbook strategies, one honest scoreboard — same data, same five tests.

The macd zero-line cross
68.2
PLAUSIBLE BUT FRAGILE

Full verdict →

The macd histogram flip
74.9
PLAUSIBLE BUT FRAGILE

Full verdict →

The verdict

Tested on survivorship-free NIFTY & BANKNIFTY data over ~2 decades, the MACD histogram flip scored higher on honesty (74.9/100). That means its backtest survives statistical scrutiny better — not that it will make you money. Most popular strategies score similarly mediocre; the honest move is to test your exact version.

Run either one live — free, no signup to see the score.

Run the MACD histogram flip now →

Get the monthly honest teardown

One popular strategy put on trial, in your inbox — once a month. No signals, no hype.

Educational, not financial advice. An honest backtest score measures whether a result survives statistical scrutiny — it does not predict future profit, and is not a buy or sell signal. · About · FAQ · All strategies